The following review is for the TV show, Gilmore Girls, and is not for the show Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life. I will be writing a separate review for that.
As with many other popular favorites, Gilmore Girls continues to have a dedicated fan base. From being able to relate to Lorelai’s love of coffee and relationship issues with her parents to Rory’s passion and sometimes fear for her future, for many viewers of the comedy-drama, tuning into the show was love at first sight.
I think Gilmore Girls is a wonderful show. I especially love the bond between Lorelai and Rory. While many shows claim to mainly be about the connection between relatives, it truly is the case here. Also, Gilmore Girls is packed with emotion and is the only show that has ever had the ability to move me to tears.
In addition to great characters, Gilmore Girls has charm. I love the witty banter, the comedy sprinkled throughout the episodes, and the overall feel of the show. I’ve seen the show at least three times all the way through now and would happily watch it again. No doubt about it.
With all the love I have for the show, there are some things that thoroughly irritate me. For one thing, I hate the changes they make to Rory’s character. I understand people grow up and with age, they change. However, Rory seems to go backwards, losing maturity instead of gaining it; doing things she never would have before. Yes, the show is fiction, but still. It’s annoying.
Another issue I have with the show is a characteristic they gave to Lorelai. She has a way of not just dating men, but making it as though falling in love is the simplest thing in the world. Somehow she can go from loving someone to ‘truly loving someone else’ in what seems to be a minute’s time. I never thought I’d say this, but I would almost prefer it if she just had flings and admitted to it than claim to be madly in love with almost everyone she is with through the length of the show.
While I do have the two above complaints, I will say this. At least the characters are given flaws. The writers of Gilmore Girls do not pretend that their creations are perfect – far from it. Don’t believe me? Just look at some of the men that Lorelai and Rory sleep with and/or date! For the record, out of everyone Lorelai is with, I definitely pick Luke. I’m not in love with any of Rory’s boyfriends, but I like Dean the best. After all, he’s always there for Rory and for the most part, quite respectful.
All in all, I give Gilmore Girls an A. It’s a wonderful show with great characters.