I first heard about Ginny and Georgia when I was scrolling through an article about the newest shows on Netflix. The first thing that caught my attention in the summary was the comparison made to Gilmore Girls. The show even has a scene where Georgia compares herself and her daughter to the women from Stars Hollow. Except, Georgia claims that they have bigger boobs than Lorelei and Rory.
Let me tell you something, bigger breasts is not where the differences end with the four characters or the show in general. Don’t get me wrong, I didn’t expect Ginny and Georgia to be exactly like Gilmore Girls (I wasn’t sure it would be like it all, for that matter), but I was hoping that it would be more like it than not. Boy, was I wrong.
First of all, the only similarity I really see between Gilmore Girls and Ginny and Georgia is that both Lorelai and Georgia had their daughters when they were young. While Lorelai had good grades when younger, Georgia was more rebellious; often found running with the wrong crowd and getting into trouble – even more serious trouble than getting pregnant. I won’t give out too much information, but let’s just say that as far as I know, Lorelai never held a gun as a teenager.
Now let’s compare – or rather not compare – Ginny with Rory. While both girls are smart, Ginny is often seen following the crowd. In the first couple of episodes, it portrays Ginny as someone who is strong and independent. Soon enough though, we see that Georgia hits the nail on the head when she describes Ginny as a ‘stereotypical, angsty teen girl’. Ginny, unlike Rory, is constantly complaining about her mother and really, her entire life.
Don’t get me wrong, things are hard for Ginny. Again, I won’t give too much away. When it comes to things being hard, I also get that teens can have it rough. We all have times of difficulty and we all struggle sometimes. Still, I feel like the show portrays every single teenager as riddled with issues, secrets, and overall depression. Not every teen has an awful life. Not every teenager is depressed or hiding some big, dark secret.
Let’s continue talking about the show in general, and not just in comparison to Gilmore Girls. In general, the show is okay. I didn’t think this is how it would turn out, but I find myself way more interested in how things turn out for Georgia than I do for Ginny. I also, unexpectedly, like Georgia better. Yes, she does and did things in her past and present I don’t always approve of, but she’s a more interesting, rounded character. She’s fun to watch and oftentimes, she’s funny and full of spunk. I find myself often annoyed with Ginny. While Georgia can be manipulative and full of hidden agendas, she is who she is. Ginny is hypocritical and oftentimes rude.
Before I conclude this review, I want to mention the character of Austin. The summary I read made it like the show was mostly about Ginny and Georgia, mother and daughter. While perhaps true, there is a son and brother in the picture. This is yet another way the show differs from the dramedy that is Gilmore Girls.
Again, whether comparing the show to GIlmore Girls or not, I find it filled with some substantial annoyances. From stereotypical teen portrayals to some highly annoying character traits, Ginny and Georgia is a show that while decent, definitely lacks something special.
All in all, I give the drama a B-. Some of the characters and plots are entertaining, but some things are way too typical and cliche. If the show returns for a second season, I’m not sure I’ll be watching.